GILBERTSONInvestigations Inc. (239) 571-1840
Failure to Train & Monell · Hiring & Retention

Hiring &
Retention

$42M
Plaintiff settlements & judgmentsSecured by retaining counsel in matters since 2014 · See the case file

Direct line: (239) 571-1840  ·  GregoryGilbertson@proton.me

Attorney and law-firm inquiries only

Some cases begin years before the incident, in a background check that missed what it should have caught or a personnel file that kept growing without consequence. Hiring and retention analysis reads that history against accepted practice.

From the Bench
U.S. District Court Western District of Washington

Never excluded. Professor Gilbertson’s testimony has not been excluded at trial in any state or federal court.

Ruling on a motion to exclude his testimony in Alvarez v. King County, No. C16-0721RAJ, 2017 WL 3189025 (W.D. Wash. July 27, 2017), Judge Richard A. Jones entered the following opinion.

“Mr. Gilbertson’s qualifications demonstrate extensive experience in policing. His expansive work as a police officer in Georgia, with assignments as a SWAT team officer, juvenile court investigator, school resource officer, stakeout squad officer, senior patrolman, and patrolman; then a career as a tenured college professor and university lecturer teaching criminal justice courses to degree-seeking students at colleges and universities, and as a licensed private investigator conducting felony pretrial investigations for attorneys in Washington State in dozens of criminal cases, makes him unique in the field of police expert witnesses. The Court finds that, based on his experience, Mr. Gilbertson’s testimony can be expected to have a reliable basis in knowledge and experience of police practices.”

The Hon. Richard A. Jones United States District Judge
The Scope

What this covers.

Within this engagement

  • Officer hiring and background screening
  • Negligent officer retention
  • Prior complaints and disciplinary history
  • Early-warning systems
  • Command review and corrective action
How it is analyzed

Pre-employment and background records where produced, personnel and disciplinary files, early-warning data, and the agency's hiring and retention policies, against national personnel standards.

Engagement terms and the published fee schedule: For Retaining Counsel →

Questions

Before the record is sent.

When does retention become the story?
When the file shows the agency knew: complaints, discipline, or warnings that accumulated while the officer stayed on the street. The analysis documents that knowledge trail.
What does retention cost?
A non-refundable $9,000 flat fee covering discovery review and the written expert report, with a bullet-point outline approved with counsel before writing begins. The full published schedule is on the For Counsel page.
Retain

Send the hiring and retention file.

Attorney and law-firm inquiries only. Conflicts are checked before anything substantive, and you will hear about a conflict immediately.

Hiring & retention inquiry

For counsel examining background, hiring, or retention decisions.

Inquiry sent.

You will hear back directly. If the matter is urgent, call (239) 571-1840.

(239) 571-1840Direct line, Naples, Florida GregoryGilbertson@proton.meDirect email, prefilled for this matter.
Nationwide practiceRetained in 42 states and D.C. · Based in Naples, FL

Conflicts are checked before any substantive discussion. Please do not send privileged material with a first inquiry; after retention the record is exchanged on physical media. Gregory consults for attorneys and their staff only, and does not provide legal advice or attorney referrals to individuals.

Back to Failure to Train & Monell